Let’s start with the March positives from the monthly chart above. Keep in mind that monthly candles are a slow-moving train. In the monthly candle for March, we see the low and high coming in slightly higher than in February. Price is holding the 5-month line, and the candle recovered most of the February losses. The performance is impressive, to be sure. Cycle theorists now believe that the March low was also the 18-month cycle low.
I am showing the next short-term cycle low arriving around the May 2nd Fed meeting. Coincidence? Highly unlikely.
There have been buyers between the 21-month line (green) and the 5-month line (red) – leaving spike lows on the chart for February and March. In particular, buyers have been strong below 4375. However, we also know that most of these buyers covered short positions. That is not the same as long-term, institutional investing.
From the monthly and longer-term perspective, price is still in a long-term uptrend, holding in the upper half of the 2009 bull market channel and the upper half of the 100-year price channel. There are very few periods over the years of more than two or three successive down months – so a green candle for March is not an unusual pause after red candles for January and February.
But March had some negatives too. We are coming from nosebleed territory outside the 3-ATR K-bands and at the multi-timeframe intersection of channel tops. In similar cases, the price will dip below the K-Bands, and often rally back toward the 2-ATR K-band before it rolls over again. That process appears to be underway now and also explains (or causes) the rally.
We can draw a downtrend line from the January and March peaks. We can also calculate a Fibonacci target at 3500, a 1.618 projection of the current downtrend, and the middle of the 2009 bull channel. I am calling 3500 our first intermediate target if the downtrend continues. See our Current Stock Market Thesis for more details on this target.
The January and February monthly candles have a massive 500 point range due to the increased volatility. As I often preach, every candle is a trading range. We can use the February low around 4100 and the March high around 4600 as a default (wide-birth) breakout range. But you can twiddle many thumbs while the market runs around in a 500 point candle range, waiting for a breakout.
For now, it is easier to use the March candle to define the upside breakout because we don’t have too far to go to take out the March high at 4630. If we saw acceptance above 4630, the worst case is a test of the all-time-high and a trading range.
The best case would be a melt-up to new highs. I cannot eliminate that possibility, but it would not be my most probable forecast.
Getting down to the bottom of the range is a lot of points from here. Given that 4470 to 4500 is where so many key levels congregate, any acceptance below 4475 is somewhat ominous even before we get to the bottom of the two previous monthly candles and the 21-Month line just above 4100.
Also, since the February and March, candles have established a 500-point balance range; breaking the bottom projects an equal, 500-point measured move down from 4100. That also places a target at 3500. So the 3500 level target results from several traditional measures.
Conclusion
My takeaway from March is that we are still in a long-term uptrend, while the intermediate trend remains broken. Perhaps that is the chief distinction between a correction and a bear market. Until the long-term trend breaks, traders have merely wounded the bull market with a standard (and long overdue) correction.
A break above 4631 virtually assures a retest of the January high and likely new highs. New highs would be the most confounding path to Wall Street. I don’t expect new highs, but I cannot exclude extending the current rally.
We will drill down to the lower boundaries on the daily and weekly reports, but the more time the market spends below 4500, the more challenging it gets to hope for a test of the old highs. Break 4100 and 3500 is the next train station.
It is too early to make projections from the 3500 target if price gets there. The level may form the bottom of a new trading range, and we will start back up again.Â
Stay flexible.
A.F. Thornton